DragonFly BSD
DragonFly kernel List (threaded) for 2003-10
[Date Prev][Date Next]  [Thread Prev][Thread Next]  [Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: packaging system

From: James Frazer <jfrazer@xxxxxxxx>
Date: Thu, 30 Oct 2003 17:55:16 -0600

Emiel Kollof wrote:

>>Compiling glibc, moz, X or
>> even KDE is NO FUN on a measly PII 400.

It's worse on a p166 :-)

Eric wrote:

> The first is that the base system is tied to portage.  I really prefer
> *BSD's way of keeping system builds separate from ports.  I've got a
> couple of foot holes from working with Gentoo in this regard.  We've
> started a policy of not upgrading portage for at least 3 days after a
> new revision and many revisions have been downgraded within a day or so.

This doesn't sound so much of a problem with portage but more a problem of not-so-great code getting released prematurely. I have friends who run Gentoo who have reportedly had the same problems though.

I personally can see benefits of being able to update the base-system through ports/packages. Obviously there are some potential drawbacks to this -- but I think it would be a bit easier (and less cryptic) as far as patching and updating the system is concerned.

Let me just give you an example -- the silly OpenSSH holes -- updating OpenSSH was a little silly -- seeing as how OpenSSH is included in base AND in the ports. You could install the new version via the port but then you would have to uninstall the version in base. Unless you wanna cvsup an update to the system sources and then muck with compiling stuff that way (how many sys-admins wanna do this?).

Perl was removed from the base system for similiar reasons. Keeping the base version up-to-date was too hard -- and installing a more up-to-date version from ports created a number of inconsistencies/problems for perl developers. (from what I remember)

It's not really that these things are hard to figure out, they just pose an additional nuisance. Portage's improvements on the *BSD port system are debateable.

This is how I see it anyway.


[Date Prev][Date Next]  [Thread Prev][Thread Next]  [Date Index][Thread Index]